Video
Product Review: "Matrox Breaks Through"
Written
by George Avgerakis
February
28 |
|
Note: For the reader's convenience, products mentioned in this
article have been highlighted in hypertext. Clicking the hypertext
will take you to the appropriate "full specifications"
page at the site our sponsor site, B &H Photo Video (www.bhphotovideo.com).
Simply click the "Back" button of your browser to return
to this article. By reviewing the specifications, you will be
assured of the most up-to-date information on these products.
At the end of the article you will find a link to the B&H
page that best relates to the title of this article.
The market
for low cost, real time, dual stream nonlinear editing hardware
has just heated up with the introduction of three new engines
from the Matrox garage. Based on the successful DigiSuite chassis,
DigiSuite
LX MAX, DigiSuite
LE MAX and DigiSuite
DTV MAX present a serious challenge to Matrox's chief competitor,
Leitch DPS and other hardware manufacturers catering to the Intel
platform. The "MAX" category adds a higher level to
Matrox's overall line, which starts at the entry level with the
RT 2500 ($899) and the RTMac board (which adds real time effects
to the Apple's Final Cut Pro & Adobe Premiere), followed by
the full Digisuite boardset ($9,995) which was debuted in 1996.
(All prices quoted are manufacturer's list.)
The Line up
In the design of the three new boardsets, Matrox has advanced
the proposition that there are three distinct categories of video
producers in its potential customer universe and designed the
boardsets that best suit each.DigiSuite LX MAX ($5,995) is aimed
at the corporate and long form producer who primarily shoots in
DV format.
Capable of both native-DV editing and MPEG-2 I-frame editing
at up to 50 Mbps, LX offers significant advantages at an attractive
price by limiting its format envelope to the expectations of a
large category of end users.
Rarely, if ever, do DV producers require non-compressed acquisition
or the ability to acquire such esoteric formats as DigiBeta or
D-9 on a serial digital interface, so these capabilities are segregated
out into an SDI (serial digital interface) option which is available
for the LX as a digital module that includes SDI I/O & AES
/ EBU digital audio.
The typical DV format producer will, however, need fast MPEG-1
and MPEG-2 encoding for CD and DVD production and I'm here to
tell you that the LX can whip out DVD compliant MPEG-2 video files
at real play time - in one pass. And when it makes these files,
it renders the files that are compliant (MPEG-2 compression wrapped
in AVI) with the most popular DVD authoring software from Sonic
Solutions (DVDit, RealDVD and Scenarist).
DPS Reality hardware, which, even when employing the hardware
accelerator, takes significantly longer than real time to create
DVD compliant files. DigiSuite LE MAX ($5,995) is targeted to
high-end postproduction houses, commercial editors, animators
and compositors because it offers acquisition and editing that
is fairly close to uncompressed.
The most similar engine on the market to Leitch DPS's Reality
engine, DigiSuite LE MAX runs M-JPEG, which allows variable acquisition
rates from a nearly transparent 5 MBps up to 15 MBps per dual
stream (or a combined, single stream bitrate of 30 MBps for a
compression ration of 1.3:1). For those of you who would like
to compare this quality to the DV format, DV operates at 25 Megabits
per second. 15 Megabytes per second, the highest bitrate of the
LE, is equivalent to 120 megabits per second, or nearly five times
the bitrate of DV.
Although DigiSuite LE MAX sells for the same price as LX, it
will require significantly greater amounts of hard drive support
due to the large size of M-JPEG files.DigiSuite DTV MAX at $7,995
is the priciest and most versatile of the three systems. Producers
employing the DTV system can combine native DV material with higher
resolution forms of digital tape such as DV 50 4:2:2 sources.
DTV also supports MPEG-2 I-frame editing at up to 50 Mbps. DTV
seems best suited for project studios and editing facilities that
want to maintain the highest degree of flexibility in terms of
working with various compression formats, allowing easy mixing
of DV and DV50 material.
As configured, the system will assist in the production of video
productions, CDs, DVDs and streaming website content.Editing InterfaceAt
present, Matrox systems are designed to operate the Adobe Premiere
6.0 NLE (nonlinear editing) software, which comes bundled with
all DigiSuite MAX platforms. A lesser-known software, known as
Incite, an NLE product from IMC, a Swiss manufacturer, may also
be used DigiSuite Max systems. In addition to the interface and
functionality of these two NLE systems, Matrox adds its own interfaces
and controls, which appear within appropriate windows of Premiere
and Incite.For instance, within the Filter and Transition windows
of Premier, Matrox inserts its own list of available tools that
efficiently drive the Matrox hardware.Users who are already familiar
with the ubiquitous Premiere on other systems will find the transition
to a Matrox system nearly seamless, while users who wish a more
professional NLE layout can explore Incite, which is similar to
the higher end software products offered by Avid, Leitch DPS and
Media 100.
Bundled Software
In addition to Adobe Premiere 6.0, Matrox systems come bundled
with a wide array of software, including Inscriber CG (for character
generation), Inscriber Video Clipboard (for instant video output
of still graphics), Ligos LSX-MPEG plug-in for Premier (creates
MPEG-1 and MPEG-2 files), Sonic Solutions Reel DVD (Sonic's mid-range
DVD authoring program which sells for $1500), Artel Boris FX (advanced
compositing features), and several Matrox programs.Hardware LimitationsAll
Matrox DigiSuite MAX configurations offer two channels of real
time video with one channel of graphics or one channel of video
with two channels of graphics.
The graphic channels need not be wedded to a layer as an overlay,
but may be placed as foreground, background or between layers.
I found that up to 15 simultaneous effects could be combined without
the need for rendering. These were one transition, one channel
of 2D DVE (including scale, crop and position), one channel of
3D DVE (including scale, rotation, position and cropping), one
Flex 3D effect (blur, page curl, distortion, etc.), two linear
keys (graphics), two channels of YUV color correction, two special
effects filters (tint, mosaic, posterize, etc), two chroma/luma/matte
keys (for graphics or video), two streams of variable speed motion
control and three fades.Each of the above effects is obtained
from proprietary Matrox control interfaces which work as Premiere
plug-ins. Each is intuitive and easy to use. A slider features
easy access to key frames which may be added to a clip to identify
points within the clip where control data changes from moment
to moment.
"Linear" and "spline" playback controls provide
both rigid and rubbery adherence through key frames although there
is no control for the amount of spline influence or a graphic
tool to manipulate the shape of a spline curve. At times when
an effect must be rendered, Matrox renders about 30% faster than
DPS hardware, making the DigiSuite MAX platforms among the fastest
renderers on the market.AcquisitionSeveral NLE manufacturers have
been offering a form of capture automation for DV tapes which
employs the "start data bit" which is recorded on a
DV tape whenever the camera is triggered to record. Pinnacle,
Canopus and other manufacturers allow users to insert a DV tape
into a compliant VCR, press "capture" and begin an automatic
process of capturing every clip and storing the results in a gallery,
ready for selection, deleting and editing. The only drawback of
this feature is that the time required for the process is twice
the play time of the tape.
This is because most systems require one pass to identify the
start bits and another pass to acquire the footage. Matrox's "scan
and capture" feature accomplishes this task in a single pass,
thus halving the time to acquire.Unique EffectsMatrox offers a
wide array of real time effects, some of which are unique to the
MAX lineup. One particularly useful effect is Blur, which up to
now, required render intensive programs like Adobe After Effects
or Eyeon Fusion. Matrox Blur, which is real time, and keyframeable,
can be applied to text or video and using another plug in you
can even create blurred independent shadowing of the blurred object
on a background layer. Mask Effect employs any 8-bit gradient
TGA image as a source mask upon which, video can be projected
and through which another track of video may be revealed.
An impressive feature of Matrox hardware is its true 3D DVE engineering,
which, for instance, allows a superimposed title to be curled
back over itself while revealing the backmost portion of the title.
DPS Reality engines cannot execute this effect.Supporting DrivesMatrox
systems are not very particular in their selection of media hard
drives. While fast SCSSI drives are preferred, lower cost IDE
drive arrays, such as those offered by Medea, may also be used.
Matrox recommends that users dedicate a set of four, striped drives
for media storage, but the drives may be any mix of sizes and
types.
The drives can reside anywhere on the computer's bus and remain
accessible to all other computer functions.Matrox systems work
well over optical SAN (storage array networks) platforms and are
suitable for multiple workstations that draw from a common source
of media files, such as a large editing or broadcast facility
or an educational facility. Such a SAN would have to obtain a
bandwidth of 80 MBps, but such hardware is available off the shelf
for prices that would make sense in a facility with four or more
workstations.Test PlatformWe tested the Matrox LX system installed
on an IBM Intellistation equipped with two Pentium IV, 1.2 GHz
processors, 512 MB RAM and a stiped set of four Seagate 36 gigabyte
Cheetah drives totaling over 100 gig's.
Matrox recommends a dual Pentium III, 700 KHz platforms with
256 MB RAM as the minimum workstation for any of the DigiSuite
MAX systems. The Matrox website offers extensive informational
screens with a wide array of acceptable workstation configurations,
including the HP WX8000, the Dell and others, as well as a global
list of certified Matrox integrators who will build a system fit
to your requirements and budget.
|